OVER 3000 HOCKEY LEGENDS PROFILED! SEARCH BY ALPHABETICAL LISTING

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T UVW XYZ

Showing posts with label Hockey's Top 100. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hockey's Top 100. Show all posts

March 22, 2018

100 Greatest Hockey Players Of All Time

What follows is a listing of the 100 greatest hockey players of all time, in my opinion. As discussed earlier, the definition of greatness is a very personalized endeavor and there is absolutely nothing wrong with it.

While there is no way of ever truly ranking the top 100 definitively, it is important for the creators of such lists to be open and transparent of how the came to their conclusions. That accountability allows the reader to better understand the process. 

Although admittedly I'm using a completely unscientific formula, I weigh career achievements (era statistics, awards, championships) and legacy (impact on and off ice, peak dominance) equally high. I rank player ability as the third most important ingredient, as first and foremost as a tie breaker. Hence, I'm not necessarily looking for the better player, as in text book definitions of what a hockey player should be, but for players with the greatest careers and greatest legacies. Therefore the best player is not necessarily the greatest player. 

The list actually came together fairly quickly, because I constantly cross-referenced other lists. I first ranked players by position, and by era, and by nationality. When I created my master list of the top 100 players of all time, I held myself accountable by staying true to those previously made lists. Some tweaking was necessary, of course, but before I adjusted the top 100 list, I had to make sure I stayed true to my original lists.

Without further ado, I present the GreatestHockeyLegends.com Top 100 Greatest Hockey Players of All Time:



1. Wayne Gretzky (C)  - "The Great One" wanted to be the best every day. He was not the most physically gifted, but with unmatchable passion and intelligence he did more with less. More than anyone else, by leaps and bounds.

2. Bobby Orr (D) - The perfect hockey player. I would concede he had the greatest career if he lasted longer. Unfortunately that if always enters that conversation, making it impossible for me to grant him top billing.

3. Gordie Howe (RW) - Hockey is a man's game. "Mr. Hockey" is the man. Both Bobby Orr and Wayne Gretzky will tell you Gordie was the greatest player ever.

4. Mario Lemieux (C) -  Super Mario was the most gifted player ever, even more talented than Bobby Orr. The same if enters the conversations regarding Lemieux.

5. Rocket Richard (RW) - More than a hockey player: Rocket's incomparable legacy transcended the game to reach religious levels in Quebec and beyond. Simply amazing.

6. Jean Beliveau (C) - Head of the Class: Hockey's original gentle giant set the standard of class and excellence in Montreal that lasts to this day.

7. Bobby Hull (LW) - The Golden Jet reached amazing heights. He one of the rare true superstars in a sporting world that overuses that term far too liberally.

8. Guy Lafleur (RW) - Every goal was an event for The Flower

9. Eddie Shore (D) - Old Time Hockey! Eddie Shore was the main event in the hockey world in the early days of the NHL's existence. He dominated and entertained like few others all from the blue line. Only Orr joins Shore as defensemen who were the best player in the world.

10. Patrick Roy (G) - St. Patrick saved the day. I figure each block of 10 in my ranking of 100 should have at least one goaltender. Patrick Roy is universally considered to be the greatest goalie of all time.

11-20
Doug Harvey (D) - Firewagon Hockey
Stan Mikita (C) - Overshadowed by Hull, Mikita may have been better
Howie Morenz (C) - The NHL's first superstar
Dominik Hasek (G) - Unorthodox Dominator reached highest peak
Ray Bourque (D) - Out of the shadows of Orr
Mark Messier (C) - Edmonton's native son became Manhattan's messiah
Sidney Crosby (C) - Player of Destiny
Jaromir Jagr (RW) - Based on talent alone, Jagr is a top ten player
Phil Esposito (C) - The Most Underrated Superstar?
Mike Bossy (RW) - The best pure goal scorer of all time?

21-30
Steve Yzerman (C) - Stevie Wonder did it all

Jacques Plante (G) - Plante changed the face of hockey
Nicklas Lidstrom (D) - Ageless Wonder
Denis Potvin (D) - Captain of the Isles dynasty
Ted Lindsay (LW) - Anything but terrible
Bryan Trottier (C) - The most complete player of his day
Joe Sakic (C) - No Ordinary Joe
Henri Richard (C) - Overshadowed, but little brother was more complete player
Valeri Kharlamov (LW) - Soviet star never had chance to play in NHL
Larry Robinson (D) - The prototypical NHL defenseman for any era

31-40
Paul Coffey (D) - Greatest skater rivalled Orr's heights
Terry Sawchuk (G) - Perfect Goalie, Imperfect World
Vladislav Tretiak (G) - A hero's legacy on both sides of the Atlantic
Red Kelly (D) - Superstar at two positions
Alexander Ovechkin (LW) - Alexander The Great
Marcel Dionne (C) - Scoring King
Bobby Clarke (C) - Great Villain, Great Hero
Viacheslav Fetisov (D) - Freedom Fighter
King Clancy (D) - Heart of the Maple Leafs
Jari Kurri (RW) - More Than A Wing Man

41-50
Peter Stastny (C) - Second Highest Scoring Player of 1980s
Boom Boom Geoffrion (RW) - Loud And Proud
Martin Brodeur (G) - Hockey's Winningest Goalie
Peter Forsberg (C) - Swede Sensation
Glenn Hall (G) - Mr. Goalie
Brett Hull (RW) - Hull of a shot
Frank Mahovlich (LW) - The Big M
Ron Francis (C) - Quiet Excellence
Milt Schmidt (C) - Mr. Boston Bruins
Dickie Moore (LW) - The Man Who Would Make The Fans Forget About The Rocket

51-60
Ken Dryden (G) - The Thinker
Syl Apps (C) - The Perfect Gentleman
Bill Durnan (G) - Ambidextrous Puck Stopper
Sergei Makarov (RW) - Rushin' Russia
Cyclone Taylor (D) - Hockey's First Legend
Brad Park (D) - In Bobby's Shadow
Bill Cook (RW) - Greatest Right Winger Before Howe, Richard
Ted Kennedy (C) - Heart of the Leafs Dynasty
Max Bentley (C) - Dipsy Doodle Dandy
Teemu Selanne (RW) - The Finnish Flash

61-70
Borje Salming (D) - Hockey's Most Important Player?
Chris Chelios (D) - Captain America
Newsy Lalonde (C) - Extra! Extra!
Chris Pronger (D) - Dastardly Good
Scott Stevens (D) - Captain Crunch
Pierre Pilote (D) - Last Of His Kind
Bill Cowley (C) - Early Day Gretzky
Gilbert Perreault (C) - Gil The Thrill
Dit Clapper (D) - Star Forward, Superstar Defenseman
Joe Malone (C) - NHL's First Scoring Star

71-80
Charlie Conacher (RW) - The Big Bomber
Elmer Lach (C) - Centre of Attention
Dave Keon (C) - Beloved Maple Leaf
Jonathan Toews - Captain Serious
Eric Lindros (C) - Reviled But Dominant
Luc Robitaille (LW) - Cool Hand Luc
Frank Boucher (C) - A Beautiful Mind
Johnny Bucyk (LW) - Boston's Chief
Andy Bathgate (RW) - Sharp Shooter
Turk Broda (G) - Playoff Hero

81-90
Tim Horton (D) - Blue Line Stud to Coffee Legend
Brian Leetch (D) - American Beauty
Serge Savard (D) - Minister of Defense
Sergei Fedorov (C) - Larger Than Life
Frank Nighbor (C) - Early Genius
Busher Jackson (LW) - Controversial Superstar
Bernie Parent (G) - Philly's Playoff MVP
Toe Blake (LW) - Great Player Turned Great Coach
Doug Bentley (LW) - No One Trick Pony
Charlie Gardiner (G) - The Smiling Scotsman

91-100
Pavel Bure (RW) - The Russian Rocket
Scott Niedermayer (D) - Hockey's Winningest Man
Pavel Datsyuk (C) - Dats Incredible!
Aurel Joliat (LW) - The Little Giant
Earl Siebert (D) - Rearguard Roughian 
Al MacInnis (D) - Big Shot
Bob Gainey (LW) - Admired By Russians
Sid Abel (C) - Enabling The Production Line
Johnny Bower (G) - The China Wall
Yvan Cournoyer (RW) - The Roadrunner

October 06, 2016

Rethinking Hockey's Top 100 Players: The Active Players



This week I have begun rethinking Hockey's Top 100 players. There has been special focus on active players Sidney Crosby, Alexander Ovechkin and Jaromir Jagr.

The only other active player on my 2013 list was Pavel Datsyuk, who squeaked in at 92.

If there is one active player who I see definitely making the updated list, it would be Jonathan Toews. He has been consistently ranked up there with Crosby and Ovechkin as this era's best player. His resume is impressive.

Ultimately Toews will find himself ranked somewhere in the upper half with the likes of Steve Yzerman, Joe Sakic, Bryan Trottier, Clarke and Henri Richard. But until his career is complete, it is premature to rank him that highly.

What other active players should be strongly considered? I'm thinking Jarome Iginla and Joe Thornton are strong candidates. Marian Hossa, Henrik and Daniel Sedin and Ryan Getzlaf and Corey Perry deserve consideration. How about Zdeno Chara and Duncan Keith on defense?

Is Patrick Kane far enough into his career to consider top 100 placement? How about Steven Stamkos?

Other skaters I will have consider include Evgeni Malkin, Henrik Zetterberg, Patrik Elias and Shea Weber.

And of course there are goalies - Are any of Roberto Luongo, Henrik Lundqvist, Ryan Miller, Marc-Andre Fleury, Pekka Rinne, Jonathan Quick or Carey Price ready to pass Billy Smith or Johnny Bower, the last two goalies to crack my top 100 list? To be honest, I don't think so, though Price still has time on his side.

Feel free to contact me as I am interested in hearing any input.

Rethinking Hockey's Top 100: On Jaromir Jagr


There has been a real love-in for Jaromir Jagr in the last couple of seasons. Hockey's oldest player continues to produce at an impressive rate in an increasingly young man's game.

It's a great story, absolutely. But is it really doing enough to see him move up the Hockey's Top 100 list significantly?

Now had Jagr led the Florida Panthers on a deep Stanley Cup playoff run, that might just do that. It would show Jagr as a great leader, something that he has not gotten a lot of credit for.

Likewise, had Jagr challenged for scoring titles at this age, it would have me really thinking.

But, at the risk of pissing off everyone who seems to love Jagr these days, ultimately I see his last few years as a vagabond nicely extending his career.

Back in 2013 I had Jagr ranked 26th overall. I'm not sure he's done enough to pass anyone on the list above him. Joe Sakic is immediately ahead at 25th.

Jagr was also further capped as the third best European player of all time. Dominik Hasek (20) and Nicklas Lidstrom (21) are ahead. While I do believe Jagr is the greatest European forward of all time, I'm not sure he has surpassed Hasek or Lidstrom.

My bigger question is am I giving enough credit to the Europeans in general here?

I had 16 ranked in the top 100 back in 2013, including four Soviet players who primarily played outside of the National Hockey League.

And my top ranked European - Hasek - was only ranked 20th.

I may need to rethink that.

October 05, 2016

Rethinking The Top 100: Alexander Ovechkin



Alexander Ovechkin's place in hockey history is the focus of my rethinking of the top 100 players in hockey history.

Back in 2013 I had ranked Ovie at 46th. Since then he has re-established himself as the most dominant goal scorer of his generation, and as such as one of the greatest goal scorers ever. Undeniably.

His career is continuing, obviously. Assuming he stays in the NHL and does not return to Russia at some point, it will be interesting to see just how high his goal scoring totals will be. It is not inconceivable he could rank as high as #2 overall. There is even an outside chance he could catch Wayne Gretzky for #1 overall, 

Obviously his detractors will tell you he has never won anything. His Washington Capitals remain a powerhouse and the window is still very much open for Ovie to get his Stanley Cup ring.

But the underlying theme in Ovechkin's career, both in the NHL and internationally, is his teams come up short. And always second to Sidney Crosby. Be it to Pittsburgh, or especially to Canada, winning has never been a word associated with Alexander Ovechkin. It is unfortunate, but a reality. 

So where does Alexander Ovechkin rank in the top 100 players of all time as of 2017?

Honestly, I think he could rank as high as the top left winger of all time by the time his career is done. In 2013 I already had him ranked as the fourth best, with Bobby Hull, Ted Lindsay and countryman Valeri Kharlamov ahead of him. 

Until he wins a Stanley Cup or a best-on-best Olympics, I will have to keep him behind Hull and Lindsay. But has his legacy allowed him to supplant Kharlamov as the greatest Russian player ever?

Kharlamov has long been the most revered player in Russian hockey history, the player every player dreams of being. He is the Gretzky of Russian hockey, so to speak. 

Time has seen Kharlamov's impact looking to had off that torch to the next generation. Sergei Fedorov may have briefly touched that torch, but Ovechkin has clearly been the torch bearer for sometime now. This legacy can not be underrated. In particular, Ovechkin has reinstated pride in the Russian national team and in Russian hockey. He is the face of Russian hockey, Russian sport, and maybe, Russia itself.

The question is, at this stage of his career has he surpassed not only Valeri Kharlamov (28th overall), but Vladislav Tretiak (33rd) and Viacheslav Fetisov (37th)?

In 2013 I created a series of lists to keep all players in check, so to speak. That means I ranked European greats in their separate lists, and when I created the top 100 master list, I had to respect the sub-lists based on positions, eras and international careers.

So in addition to deciding Ovechkin's place in Russian hockey history, I have to decide has he surpassed any other European players who ranked ahead of him in 2013. That list ranked Dominik Hasek (20th), Nicklas Lidstrom (21st), Jaromir Jagr (26th, and yes that needs to be reviewed too), Kharlamov, Tretiak, Fetisov, Jari Kurri (39th), Peter Stastny (40th) and Peter Forsberg (43rd) all outranked Ovie.

Hasek, Lidstrom and Jagr are the three greatest European NHLers, with the three aforementioned Russians ranked largely on their international careers. Has Ovechkin surpassed Kurri, Stastny and Forsberg on this list?

These are the thoughts in my head regarding Alexander Ovechkin. My feeling at this time is he will move into the 30s, ahead of Kurri, Stastny and Forsberg, but behind Tretiak and maybe Fetisov. 






Rethinking The Top 100: Sidney Crosby



Sidney Crosby is a player of destiny.

Since a young age he was hailed as the Next One, and he has fulfilled that for the most part. He has won everything there is to win, and is considered to be the top player in the game for a good portion of his career.

Despite that, in many ways he remains one of the most underrated players of all time. His game is far more complete than many other of the all time greats. Yet his offensive dominance is not necessarily obvious, partly due to some serious injuries and partly due to the era he plays in.

So when it comes to rethinking my 2013 list of hockey's top 100 players, Sidney Crosby, with a good portion of his career still to come, perplexes me.

In 2013 I already had him ranked as the 29th best hockey player of all time. Add another Olympic gold medal, another Stanley Cup, a World Cup, a World Championship, another Art Ross Trophy, another Hart Trophy, another Pearson/Lindsay Trophy and a Conn Smythe Trophy, and it is safe to say Crosby is moving up the list.

Looking back to 2013, I had 11 centers ahead of him: Gretzky, Lemieux, Beliveau, Mikita, Morenz, Esposito, Yzerman, Messier, Trottier, Sakic, and Henri Richard.

On one hand I can see Crosby moving up all the way to #4 among centers. On the other hand I have trouble ranking him higher than Mikita in particular, and Morenz, Espo and Messier.

At this stage of his career (and realistically, there is little more that he can accomplish, isn't there?) I think it is safe to say Sidney Crosby will move into the top 20 overall for certain. How close he will get to the top 10 is the next question. And there is a chance he could crack the top 10.

Pretty amazing, isn't it?

I think it will come down to this question - One game, winner takes all - Who do you want on your team? Sidney Crosby? Or the aforementioned centers? Or Ray Bourque? Or Mike Bossy? Or Nicklas Lidstrom?

That is some pretty impressive company, kid.

Be sure to tell me where you think Sidney Crosby ranks, as I will value any input.

January 19, 2016

Rethinking The Greatest 100 Hockey Players Of All Time



By far the most popular post here at GreatestHockeyLegends.com has been 2013's The Greatest 100 Hockey Players Of All Time.

Seriously. It is not even close.

It was written less than three years ago, but maybe the time has come to rethink The Greatest 100 Hockey Players Of All Time. 

My Top 100 list openly admits it is my personal selections, complete with whatever biases I have. I tried to be very open about those biases. The result has been a list been widely received as a solid list with surprisingly few disagreements.

As you may recall, the biggest debate I had was defining what it takes to be "the greatest." 

I fully believe there is a potentially huge difference between the best player and the greatest player. The best player is defined by ability and attribute. Whereas the greatest player is more about accomplishments and legacy.

Hence, when someone tells me Bobby Orr or Mario Lemieux as the best player to ever play the game, I will not argue. 

But when it comes to the greatest player - as in who had the greatest career - I firmly believe it is Wayne Gretzky.

But the time has come to revisit the entire Top 100 list. Specifically:
  1. Sidney Crosby and Alexander Ovechkin. A lot has changed since 2013, with Crosby stagnating or possibly sliding, and Ovechkin rising. This is the biggest debate at this time, with it likely being the final debate until their careers conclude.
  2. The possible inclusion of the likes of Jonathan Toews, Patrick Kane, Duncan Keith, Evgeni Malkin and Steven Stamkos.
  3. Revisiting the status of veterans like Jaromir Jagr, Jarome Iginla, Roberto Luongo and Henrik Lundqvist.
  4. Revisiting the legacies of recently retired players like Nicklas Lidstrom, Mats Sundin, Phil Housley and Martin Brodeur.
At this stage I would like to encourage anyone and everyone to share their thoughts with me, either here in the comments section, or via social media:

November 18, 2013

How Do You Define Greatness?


How do you define greatness? 

It is almost impossible to come to a conclusive answer to that question because the process is a very individual quest. As Wikipedia suggests, "Greatness is a concept that is heavily dependent on a person's perspective and biases."

So very true. Which is why I have yet to see anyone completely agree with anyone else on a list of the greatest 100 hockey players ever. These lists are opinions that are as individual as snowflakes.


I have spent the past several months mulling over my own personal ranking of the 100 greatest players in the history of hockey. But in order for me to properly do that, I think I have to come up with my own concrete definition of greatness, at least I see it. That way you, the reader, can understand my thought process. Also this holds my ranking to more transparency and accountability - something rarely offered by authors of such ventures.

Although admittedly I'm using a completely unscientific formula, I weigh career achievements (era statistics, awards, championships) and legacy (impact on and off ice, peak dominance) equally high. I rank player ability as the third most important ingredient, as first and foremost as a tie breaker. Hence, I'm not necessarily looking for the better player, as in text book definitions of what a hockey player should be, but for players with the greatest careers and greatest legacies. Therefore the best player is not necessarily the greatest player.

The list actually came together fairly quickly, because I constantly cross-referenced other lists. I first ranked players by position, and by era, and by nationality. When I created my master list of the top 100 players of all time, I held myself accountable by staying true to those previously made lists. Some tweaking was necessary, of course, but before I adjusted the top 100 list, I had to make sure I stayed true to my original lists. 

Here are some quick breakdowns of my list.

Positions represented:

Goalies: 14
Centers: 33
Right Wings: 15
Left Wings: 13
Defense: 25

By Era:

Pre-1950: 23
Original Six (1950-1967) - 24
Post Expansion (1967-current) - 53
- 1970s - 18
- 1980 - 15
- 1990s/2000s - 20

I will present my Top 100 Greatest Players in Hockey History on Tuesday. In the meantime I'd value any feed back you have on my definition, my process or my breakdown results

September 15, 2008

Hockey's Top 100: The Game's Greatest Records

Veteran hockey writers Don Weekes and Kerry Banks team up to rank all of hockey's greatest achievements in giving us Hockey's Top 100: The Game's Greatest Records, published by Greystone Books.

Read the full book review at HockeyBookReviews.com