Showing posts with label Hockey Hall of Fame 2010. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hockey Hall of Fame 2010. Show all posts
November 05, 2010
Hockey Hall of Fame Weekend
The Hockey Hall of Fame is set to induct 608 goal scorer Dino Ciccarelli and female pioneers Angela James and Cammi Granato into the player's category. In addition, Jimmy Devellano and the late Doc Seaman in the builder's category.
"The Hockey Hall of Fame is proud to welcome these five hockey legends as Honoured Members," said Jim Gregory, who along with Pat Quinn co-chairs the Hockey Hall of Fame selection committee. "Their contributions to the game of hockey are well documented and their election to the Hockey Hall of Fame is richly deserved."
Scroll through the front page of GreatestHockeyLegends.com for full details. Also, here's a look at the Class of 2011 and who will be the Next Women to be inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame
June 23, 2010
Hall of Shame
I thought Larry Brooks of the NY Post summed up the Hall's heartless call on not including Pat Burns in the class of 2010 very nicely:
Of course, just because a player is eligible does not mean his name was discussed. There is a nomination process, and only nominated players are debated and voted upon. On Fan590's Prime Time Sports radio show John Shannon suggested he had reason to believe Eric Lindros was not even nominated for discussion today.
Judging by media and public reaction to Tuesday's Hall of Fame announcement, people are pissed. I would like to think the outrage will be the beginning of a change at the Hall to a more accountable procedure. In all likelihood it will lead only to a more dismissive attitude to the selection committee and process. That only leads to disinterest.
That's the last thing we want, as that leads to irrelevancy.
Slap Shots
"Hockey HOF selection committee that meets behind closed doors and that answers to no one, disgraced itself this year bypassing Burns. ... I guess Burns was never a member of the Good Ole Boys Club that acts as the gateway to the Hall. ... If committee members have any honor, they will resign now."The public outrage goes beyond Burns' omission to the fact that the Hall should have included at least 2 more players in the men's category. In a year when there were several candidates equal to Dino Ciccarelli, they should have had the brains to agree to loosen the logjam of eligible players.
Of course, just because a player is eligible does not mean his name was discussed. There is a nomination process, and only nominated players are debated and voted upon. On Fan590's Prime Time Sports radio show John Shannon suggested he had reason to believe Eric Lindros was not even nominated for discussion today.
Judging by media and public reaction to Tuesday's Hall of Fame announcement, people are pissed. I would like to think the outrage will be the beginning of a change at the Hall to a more accountable procedure. In all likelihood it will lead only to a more dismissive attitude to the selection committee and process. That only leads to disinterest.
That's the last thing we want, as that leads to irrelevancy.
Slap Shots
- While the headlines are all about who is not included by the Hall, congratulations must go out to Ciccarelli, James, Granato, Jimmy Devellano and the late Doc Seaman for being inducted. No one is arguing against their inclusion. Let's give the Hall credit where credit is due.
- One good thing about the lack of NHL talent is that the women's game will very much be front and center come induction day in November. They would have been overshadowed had someone like Eric Lindros was named.
- Note to the NHL - proceeding the annual Hockey Hall of Fame Game on induction weekend (presumably between the Capitals and North Stars?) the NHL should arrange for a game involving the top women's players in the game today. It is time for NHL to embrace women's hockey. It's good for the game, and good for their business.
June 21, 2010
HHOF Class of 2010?
The Hockey Hall of Fame selection committee meets on Tuesday to decide who will be inducted into it's hallowed halls later this year.
Here is the summary of selection procedures and the Hall of Fame bylaws that the 18 member selection committee uses to reach their collective decision. General summary:
Referees and builders (coaches, management etc) have their category. Earlier this year the Hall of Fame announced Marc de Foy (Le Journal de Montreal) as the winner of the Elmer Ferguson Memorial Award for hockey journalism and Ron Weber (Washington Capitals play by play man) for the Foster Hewitt Memorial Award for outstanding contributions as a hockey broadcaster.
Candidates For 2010
Unlike in two of the previous three years, there is no obvious choice amongst the first year eligible candidates. Those names include: Eric Lindros, Joe Nieuwendyk, John Leclair, Peter Bondra, Pierre Turgeon, and Sean Burke.
The thin first-year class suggests a couple of hold-over candidates from previous years will get serious consideration. Such players include Theo Fleury, Doug Gilmour, Adam Oates, Sergei Makarov, Guy Carbonneau, Pavel Bure, Dino Ciccarelli, Tom Barrasso, Pat Verbeek, Mike Richter, Alexander Mogilny, Dave Andreychuk and Phil Housley
The Class of 2010?
Last week I did a series of articles outlining the respective cases of many of the top candidates. Here's a recap of the feature I called Hall of Fame Worthy?
The one player who surprised me the most was Doug Gilmour. I entered the process believing he was very much worthy, and very likely in 2010. After going through the pros and cons, I now wonder if he is of Hall of Fame calibre.
If I had a vote, my ballot would include Joe Nieuwendyk, Adam Oates, Eric Lindros, and Sergei Makarov. That is different than who I think will be announced on Tuesday. If I had to bet, my guess would be Joe Nieuwendyk, Adam Oates, Pavel Bure and Doug Gilmour will be the top four. Because there are so many candidates, each with different backers on the committee, I am not convinced that the Hall will reach the necessary 75% majority vote. Because of that we may see only 2 or 3 candidates named in 2010.
First Ladies
I also spent some time last week handicapping the candidates of female players. Choosing the first two women hockey players to be inducted is a huge honour worthy of significant discussion. It will be no easy choice. Expect one American (almost certainly Cammi Granato) and one Canadian (there are several top candidates) to be the inaugural inductees.
Builders
Unlike players, there is no set time-line for builders to wait until eligibility. Many builders are coaches and managers who are inducted well before their careers are over. This makes it hard to project the builder category.
There is much speculation that the Hall will fast track Pat Burns into builder category. The three time coach of the year and 1 time Stanley Cup champion is suffering from his third bout of cancer. The cancer in his lungs has been declared untreatable. Burns may not live long enough for another induction year.
I would like to see a couple of women get acknowledgment as builders of hockey - Hazel McCallion and Fran Rider, perhaps the two most instrumental women off the ice in the long history of women's hockey. Somehow it would seem funny to have the inaugural class of women's hockey not to include them.
It should be noted that the female category pertains to players only. Female builders are still lumped together with the men.
Also See:
Here is the summary of selection procedures and the Hall of Fame bylaws that the 18 member selection committee uses to reach their collective decision. General summary:
- Player candidates must have been retired for at least three years.
- Successful candidates will receive votes from at least 75% of the committee members
- No more than 4 players can be inducted.
Referees and builders (coaches, management etc) have their category. Earlier this year the Hall of Fame announced Marc de Foy (Le Journal de Montreal) as the winner of the Elmer Ferguson Memorial Award for hockey journalism and Ron Weber (Washington Capitals play by play man) for the Foster Hewitt Memorial Award for outstanding contributions as a hockey broadcaster.
Candidates For 2010
Unlike in two of the previous three years, there is no obvious choice amongst the first year eligible candidates. Those names include: Eric Lindros, Joe Nieuwendyk, John Leclair, Peter Bondra, Pierre Turgeon, and Sean Burke.
The thin first-year class suggests a couple of hold-over candidates from previous years will get serious consideration. Such players include Theo Fleury, Doug Gilmour, Adam Oates, Sergei Makarov, Guy Carbonneau, Pavel Bure, Dino Ciccarelli, Tom Barrasso, Pat Verbeek, Mike Richter, Alexander Mogilny, Dave Andreychuk and Phil Housley
The Class of 2010?
Last week I did a series of articles outlining the respective cases of many of the top candidates. Here's a recap of the feature I called Hall of Fame Worthy?
- Hall of Fame Worthy?
- Joe Nieuwendyk
- Doug Gilmour
- Adam Oates
- Eric Lindros
- Pavel Bure
- Peter Bondra
- Theo Fleury
- Dave Andreychuk
- The Soviets
The one player who surprised me the most was Doug Gilmour. I entered the process believing he was very much worthy, and very likely in 2010. After going through the pros and cons, I now wonder if he is of Hall of Fame calibre.
If I had a vote, my ballot would include Joe Nieuwendyk, Adam Oates, Eric Lindros, and Sergei Makarov. That is different than who I think will be announced on Tuesday. If I had to bet, my guess would be Joe Nieuwendyk, Adam Oates, Pavel Bure and Doug Gilmour will be the top four. Because there are so many candidates, each with different backers on the committee, I am not convinced that the Hall will reach the necessary 75% majority vote. Because of that we may see only 2 or 3 candidates named in 2010.
First Ladies
I also spent some time last week handicapping the candidates of female players. Choosing the first two women hockey players to be inducted is a huge honour worthy of significant discussion. It will be no easy choice. Expect one American (almost certainly Cammi Granato) and one Canadian (there are several top candidates) to be the inaugural inductees.
Builders
Unlike players, there is no set time-line for builders to wait until eligibility. Many builders are coaches and managers who are inducted well before their careers are over. This makes it hard to project the builder category.
There is much speculation that the Hall will fast track Pat Burns into builder category. The three time coach of the year and 1 time Stanley Cup champion is suffering from his third bout of cancer. The cancer in his lungs has been declared untreatable. Burns may not live long enough for another induction year.
I would like to see a couple of women get acknowledgment as builders of hockey - Hazel McCallion and Fran Rider, perhaps the two most instrumental women off the ice in the long history of women's hockey. Somehow it would seem funny to have the inaugural class of women's hockey not to include them.
It should be noted that the female category pertains to players only. Female builders are still lumped together with the men.
Also See:
June 14, 2010
Hall of Fame Debate
The 2010-11 season unofficially starts this weekend with the NHL Entry Draft and the flurry of activity that usually accompanies it. In a couple of more weeks team managements and player agents will kick off a frenzied July with the free agency period. All of this makes for very interesting off-season times.
Somewhat quietly by comparison there is another exciting event sneaking up on hockey's calendar of events. The Hockey Hall of Fame selection committee will be meeting to decide and announce the class of 2010 on June 22nd, although the actual induction will not take place until November.
The 2010 debate is the most interesting in years. For the first time in years there is no slam dunk first year candidates. The first-time eligible players likely to garner votes include:
Every player who retired three years ago is technically eligible. The selection committee must receive a formal nomination in order to consider them. So just because guys like Scott Mellanby, Mike Ricci, and Matthew Barnaby, all fine hockey players, are eligible, the Hall will almost certainly not spend any time considering them or other such players.
Of the newly eligible players, I would say Joe Nieuwendyk is the most likely to be inducted. I think Eric Lindros also deserves inclusion, but I'm far from certain either will make it on their first try. The Hall has a recent history of making non-slam dunk candidates wait. Are any of this year's newly eligible any better than these holdovers from recent years:
If I had to hazard a guess as to who the Hall of Fame will call in 2010, I would probably go with Gilmour, Oates and Bure. I suspect they will make Mr. Lindros wait, although I disagree with that.
If I had voting power, I would probably go a little differently. I believe there are at least 7 Hall of Famers in the players mentioned above. If I had a say I would probably vote for Lindros, Bure, Oates and Makarov. I know my Makarov vote would be wasted amongst this selection committee. In the interest of clearing the logjam I could be persuaded to move Nieuwendyk up to the 4th position.
Who do you think should make the grade? You tell me. I have a poll running on the right side column. You can leave comments, vote in the poll on the right side bar, join me in conversation on Twitter @HockeyLegends, or email me at teamcanada72@gmail.com.
Somewhat quietly by comparison there is another exciting event sneaking up on hockey's calendar of events. The Hockey Hall of Fame selection committee will be meeting to decide and announce the class of 2010 on June 22nd, although the actual induction will not take place until November.
The 2010 debate is the most interesting in years. For the first time in years there is no slam dunk first year candidates. The first-time eligible players likely to garner votes include:
Every player who retired three years ago is technically eligible. The selection committee must receive a formal nomination in order to consider them. So just because guys like Scott Mellanby, Mike Ricci, and Matthew Barnaby, all fine hockey players, are eligible, the Hall will almost certainly not spend any time considering them or other such players.
Of the newly eligible players, I would say Joe Nieuwendyk is the most likely to be inducted. I think Eric Lindros also deserves inclusion, but I'm far from certain either will make it on their first try. The Hall has a recent history of making non-slam dunk candidates wait. Are any of this year's newly eligible any better than these holdovers from recent years:
- Theo Fleury
- Doug Gilmour
- Adam Oates
- Sergei Makarov
- Guy Carbonneau
- Pavel Bure
- Dino Ciccarelli
- Tom Barrasso
- Pat Verbeek
- Mike Richter
- Alexander Mogilny
- Dave Andreychuk
- Phil Housley
If I had to hazard a guess as to who the Hall of Fame will call in 2010, I would probably go with Gilmour, Oates and Bure. I suspect they will make Mr. Lindros wait, although I disagree with that.
If I had voting power, I would probably go a little differently. I believe there are at least 7 Hall of Famers in the players mentioned above. If I had a say I would probably vote for Lindros, Bure, Oates and Makarov. I know my Makarov vote would be wasted amongst this selection committee. In the interest of clearing the logjam I could be persuaded to move Nieuwendyk up to the 4th position.
Who do you think should make the grade? You tell me. I have a poll running on the right side column. You can leave comments, vote in the poll on the right side bar, join me in conversation on Twitter @HockeyLegends, or email me at teamcanada72@gmail.com.
November 05, 2009
Hockey Hall of Fame: The Class of 2010?
The Hockey Hall of Fame is readying to welcome five new legends to it's hallowed halls this weekend - Brett Hull, Brian Leetch, Luc Robitaille and Steve Yzerman and builder Lou Lamoreillo.
While the hockey world is about to celebrate these five greats, the debate has already begun as to who should be included in the Hockey Hall of Fame class of 2010.
For the first time in a while there may be no obvious choice amongst the first year candidates. Perhaps this will allow for some of the huge backlog of players who have been waiting for inclusion in the past few years? It certainly will make for fascinating debate.
First, let's take a look at the players who will be gaining their first year of eligibility. Players must be retired from professional hockey (including outside of the NHL) for three seasons before they can be considered for enshrinement.
Eric Lindros - Debate over Lindros' inclusion will be highly controversial, much like several other incidents in his career.
He was hailed as The Next One, but injuries prevented him from ever fulfilling his destiny. Right from the start of his NHL career, when he refused to play for the Quebec Nordiques, a lot of fans despised Lindros. His strong-headed ways (concussions notwithstanding) did not win him a lot of friends in the media or even parts of the hockey community either.
But when he was healthy he was a dominant force, with interval statistics that challenged the best in history. He was one of the best if not the best player in hockey, although it is hard to find people with objective enough minds to agree.
Lindros belongs in the Hall of Fame. Even Bobby Clarke, his biggest enemy, said so. But I suspect the Hall will make him wait.
John Leclair - Lindros' running mate put up some great numbers in the 1990s. With Lindros missing a lot of time with injuries, Leclair proved he was more than just a side kick. Leclair won't get in this year. I would not object to him being include at some stage down the road, but for now he will have to wait in line with a long list of deserving backlogged candidates.
Joe Nieuwendyk - Nieuwendyk was a big game player who is very highly respected by everyone. That may help him get in one day, but again I think 2010 is the year we see passed over candidates get their chance.
Peter Bondra - He will not get a lot of support, but I actually think Peter Bondra should be in the Hall, though not this year necessarily. He was a consistent goal scoring threat during the dead puck era. But he was too introverted for his own good, and playing in Washington in the pre-Ovechkin days did not help with exposure. Still, I think he deserves more debate than he likely will ever get.
Pierre Turgeon - He was a great talent who never really met expectations. I see little chance of Turgeon ever getting into the HHOF.
Sean Burke - I really liked Sean Burke, but bottom line is he did not win anything significant in his career.
Every player who retired three years ago is technically eligible. The selection committee must receive a formal nomination in order to consider them. So just because guys like Scott Mellanby, Mike Ricci, and Matthew Barnaby, all fine hockey players, are eligible, the Hall will almost certainly not spend any time considering them or other such players.
We also have to bring up the name Theo Fleury. Despite his suspension for substance abuse having never been lifted, 2009 was the actually Fleury's first year of eligibility. Given his demons, there was no way he was getting in then. But now he's explained his demons with unbelieavable courage and humility, he's back on HHOF radar. I believe he will get in, but is 2010 the year?
Here is a look at hold overs with a good shot at making the grade in 2010:
Doug Gilmour - I think Doug Gilmour's wait will come to an end in 2010. He was a big game warrior and was the focal point in hockey's biggest market, Toronto. An off ice incident or two has held him back so far, but of all the players mentioned for consideration today in this article, I would have to think he was the best.
Adam Oates - If Gilmour isn't the top player, Adam Oates is. He was the best play maker of his era not named Wayne Gretzky. Playmakers often play second fiddle to their scoring partners, and Oates certainly did that with the likes of Brett Hull and Cam Neely. But Oates was just a wonderful, heady hockey player, one of the best in the business. He'll get in one day, it's just a matter of when.
Sergei Makarov - I've said it before and said it again, the best eligible player not in the HHOF is Soviet superstar Sergei Makarov. Most people remember Makarov as a Calgary Flame or San Jose Shark late in his career. But without even considering his NHL career I would include him in the Hall. For much of the 1980s Sergei Makarov was arguably the best winger in the world, probably on par with Jari Kurri or Mike Bossy. It is truly impossible to compare as Makarov was stuck behind the Iron Curtain for all those years. But his performances at the Canada Cups, the Olympics and world championships were consistently dominant for most of the decade.
He won't get it in. But he should.
Guy Carbonneau - Aside from Bob Gainey, Guy Carbonneau is universally hailed as the best defensive forward in the modern game. On TSN on Wednesday night Bobby Clarke had Carbonneau at the very top of his voting list, while Bob McKenzie and Keith Jones also had him on their unofficial ballot.
Pavel Bure - He was the most exciting player of his generation, but a controversial exit in Vancouver and a shortened career with no Stanley Cup ring does not help. I still think he belongs in the Hall. He was such an entertaining player in an era deprived of such magician. Is this the year the Hall overlooks his short comings?
Dino Ciccarelli - Over 600 goals and he's still waiting for inclusion. The career goal totals are staggering, and normally would make him a lock. But I agree with the stance that he has had to wait this long, and may wait forever. Amazing total yes, earned through amazing consistency over a long period of time. But he was never the best player or the best right winger. I have to same argument for 700 goal scorer Mike Gartner, who is already included in the Hall, of course.
Dave Andreychuk - see Dino Ciccarelli. Almost an exact carbon copy case.
Alexander Mogilny - Mogilny is an interesting case, similar to Pavel Bure. But with Mogilny there was more inconsistency, more frustration. If we took out his monstrous 76 goal season, he probably would not get a lot of consideration. To me that means he was not among the truly elite for a long enough period of time.
Phil Housley - The fourth highest scoring defenseman and at one time the highest scoring American player ever, Housley never won a championship or a Norris trophy. Only once did he make the NHL's post-season all star team. Does he get in for being a really high scoring American player? That shouldn't be enough.
If I had to hazard a guess as to who the Hall of Fame will call in 2010, I would probably go with Gilmour, Oates and Bure. I suspect they will make Mr. Lindros wait, although I disagree with that.
If I had voting power, I would probably go a little differently. I believe there are at least 7 Hall of Famers in the players mentioned above. If I had a say I would probably vote for Lindros, Bure, Oates and Makarov. I know my Makarov vote would be wasted amongst this selection committee. In the interest of clearing the logjam I could be persuaded to move Nieuwendyk up to the 4th position.
Who do you think should make the grade? You tell me. I have a poll running on the right side column. You can leave comments or email me at teamcanada72@gmail.com.
While the hockey world is about to celebrate these five greats, the debate has already begun as to who should be included in the Hockey Hall of Fame class of 2010.
For the first time in a while there may be no obvious choice amongst the first year candidates. Perhaps this will allow for some of the huge backlog of players who have been waiting for inclusion in the past few years? It certainly will make for fascinating debate.
First, let's take a look at the players who will be gaining their first year of eligibility. Players must be retired from professional hockey (including outside of the NHL) for three seasons before they can be considered for enshrinement.
Eric Lindros - Debate over Lindros' inclusion will be highly controversial, much like several other incidents in his career.He was hailed as The Next One, but injuries prevented him from ever fulfilling his destiny. Right from the start of his NHL career, when he refused to play for the Quebec Nordiques, a lot of fans despised Lindros. His strong-headed ways (concussions notwithstanding) did not win him a lot of friends in the media or even parts of the hockey community either.
But when he was healthy he was a dominant force, with interval statistics that challenged the best in history. He was one of the best if not the best player in hockey, although it is hard to find people with objective enough minds to agree.
Lindros belongs in the Hall of Fame. Even Bobby Clarke, his biggest enemy, said so. But I suspect the Hall will make him wait.
John Leclair - Lindros' running mate put up some great numbers in the 1990s. With Lindros missing a lot of time with injuries, Leclair proved he was more than just a side kick. Leclair won't get in this year. I would not object to him being include at some stage down the road, but for now he will have to wait in line with a long list of deserving backlogged candidates.
Joe Nieuwendyk - Nieuwendyk was a big game player who is very highly respected by everyone. That may help him get in one day, but again I think 2010 is the year we see passed over candidates get their chance.
Peter Bondra - He will not get a lot of support, but I actually think Peter Bondra should be in the Hall, though not this year necessarily. He was a consistent goal scoring threat during the dead puck era. But he was too introverted for his own good, and playing in Washington in the pre-Ovechkin days did not help with exposure. Still, I think he deserves more debate than he likely will ever get.
Pierre Turgeon - He was a great talent who never really met expectations. I see little chance of Turgeon ever getting into the HHOF.
Sean Burke - I really liked Sean Burke, but bottom line is he did not win anything significant in his career.
Every player who retired three years ago is technically eligible. The selection committee must receive a formal nomination in order to consider them. So just because guys like Scott Mellanby, Mike Ricci, and Matthew Barnaby, all fine hockey players, are eligible, the Hall will almost certainly not spend any time considering them or other such players.
We also have to bring up the name Theo Fleury. Despite his suspension for substance abuse having never been lifted, 2009 was the actually Fleury's first year of eligibility. Given his demons, there was no way he was getting in then. But now he's explained his demons with unbelieavable courage and humility, he's back on HHOF radar. I believe he will get in, but is 2010 the year?Here is a look at hold overs with a good shot at making the grade in 2010:
Doug Gilmour - I think Doug Gilmour's wait will come to an end in 2010. He was a big game warrior and was the focal point in hockey's biggest market, Toronto. An off ice incident or two has held him back so far, but of all the players mentioned for consideration today in this article, I would have to think he was the best.
Adam Oates - If Gilmour isn't the top player, Adam Oates is. He was the best play maker of his era not named Wayne Gretzky. Playmakers often play second fiddle to their scoring partners, and Oates certainly did that with the likes of Brett Hull and Cam Neely. But Oates was just a wonderful, heady hockey player, one of the best in the business. He'll get in one day, it's just a matter of when.
Sergei Makarov - I've said it before and said it again, the best eligible player not in the HHOF is Soviet superstar Sergei Makarov. Most people remember Makarov as a Calgary Flame or San Jose Shark late in his career. But without even considering his NHL career I would include him in the Hall. For much of the 1980s Sergei Makarov was arguably the best winger in the world, probably on par with Jari Kurri or Mike Bossy. It is truly impossible to compare as Makarov was stuck behind the Iron Curtain for all those years. But his performances at the Canada Cups, the Olympics and world championships were consistently dominant for most of the decade.
He won't get it in. But he should.
Guy Carbonneau - Aside from Bob Gainey, Guy Carbonneau is universally hailed as the best defensive forward in the modern game. On TSN on Wednesday night Bobby Clarke had Carbonneau at the very top of his voting list, while Bob McKenzie and Keith Jones also had him on their unofficial ballot.
Pavel Bure - He was the most exciting player of his generation, but a controversial exit in Vancouver and a shortened career with no Stanley Cup ring does not help. I still think he belongs in the Hall. He was such an entertaining player in an era deprived of such magician. Is this the year the Hall overlooks his short comings?Dino Ciccarelli - Over 600 goals and he's still waiting for inclusion. The career goal totals are staggering, and normally would make him a lock. But I agree with the stance that he has had to wait this long, and may wait forever. Amazing total yes, earned through amazing consistency over a long period of time. But he was never the best player or the best right winger. I have to same argument for 700 goal scorer Mike Gartner, who is already included in the Hall, of course.
Dave Andreychuk - see Dino Ciccarelli. Almost an exact carbon copy case.
Alexander Mogilny - Mogilny is an interesting case, similar to Pavel Bure. But with Mogilny there was more inconsistency, more frustration. If we took out his monstrous 76 goal season, he probably would not get a lot of consideration. To me that means he was not among the truly elite for a long enough period of time.
Phil Housley - The fourth highest scoring defenseman and at one time the highest scoring American player ever, Housley never won a championship or a Norris trophy. Only once did he make the NHL's post-season all star team. Does he get in for being a really high scoring American player? That shouldn't be enough.
If I had to hazard a guess as to who the Hall of Fame will call in 2010, I would probably go with Gilmour, Oates and Bure. I suspect they will make Mr. Lindros wait, although I disagree with that.
If I had voting power, I would probably go a little differently. I believe there are at least 7 Hall of Famers in the players mentioned above. If I had a say I would probably vote for Lindros, Bure, Oates and Makarov. I know my Makarov vote would be wasted amongst this selection committee. In the interest of clearing the logjam I could be persuaded to move Nieuwendyk up to the 4th position.
Who do you think should make the grade? You tell me. I have a poll running on the right side column. You can leave comments or email me at teamcanada72@gmail.com.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

