Skip to main content

Who Was Better? Rick Middleton vs Lanny McDonald

 Two of the most popular players for the 1970s and 1980s were wingers Rick "Nifty" Middleton and Lanny McDonald. They were different types of players yet had similar careers. 

The question we pose today is: Who was better? Rick Middleton or Lanny McDonald?

After a rocky start with the impatient New York Rangers, Rick Middleton joined the Boston Bruins and delivered surprising results. He became an exciting fan favorite, even though he was not the typical Boston hockey hero. He was not rough and tumble, but rather a fancy pants with incredible stickhandling ability especially in traffic. Add to that his great skating which featured a couple different gears to change it up and he could deke defenders right on to the highlight reel. 

Moreover, Middleton rounded out his game into a solid overall game. And he did it all very cleanly, only collecting 157 penalty minutes in over 1000 NHL games. In 1982 he won the Lady Byng Trophy in 1982. 

You can read my full Rick Middleton biography here.

Lanny McDonald's bushy mustache is his trademark, but so were such characteristics as speed, work ethic, and commitment. Those traits, not really counting his facial hair, helped make him a member of the Hockey Hall of Fame.

McDonald enjoyed his greatest season in 1982-83 when McDonald unthinkably challenged Wayne Gretzky for the NHL goal scoring total. Gretzky would end up with the crown thanks to his 71 goals, but McDonald wasn't far behind with an overachieving 66. It was simply an amazing season for McDonald.

Another amazing season was Lanny's last. He was grizzled veteran by 1989, but he scored his 500th goal, 1000th assist and, scoring a memorable playoff goal along the way, finally won his first Stanley Cup. 

You can read my full Lanny McDonald biography here.

There seems to be some consensus that Lanny is one of the more borderline Hockey Hall of Famers. Nifty is similarly borderline, but he's on the other side of the line - not enshrined.  The difference may very well be McDonald's ties to Toronto and, for that matter, Canada where he played the bulk of his career as a beloved, mustachioed face of two franchises. Middleton never played for a Canadian team, but had he excelled with Toronto for a few years, it wouldn't surprise me if he would have been inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame by now, too.

You tell me - who was better? Rick Middleton or Lanny McDonald. 


sd said…
Also, Rick Middleon retired with 988 points, we could wonder what if Rick had played one more season? He might have reached 1000 points and could his chance of being eligible to the Hockey Hall of Fame might be bigger?

Popular posts from this blog

100 Greatest Hockey Players Of All Time

What follows is a listing of the 100 greatest hockey players of all time, in my opinion. As discussed earlier, the definition of greatness is a very personalized endeavor and there is absolutely nothing wrong with it.
While there is no way of ever truly ranking the top 100 definitively, it is important for the creators of such lists to be open and transparent of how the came to their conclusions. That accountability allows the reader to better understand the process. 

Although admittedly I'm using a completely unscientific formula, I weigh career achievements (era statistics, awards, championships) and legacy (impact on and off ice, peak dominance) equally high. I rank player ability as the third most important ingredient, as first and foremost as a tie breaker. Hence, I'm not necessarily looking for the better player, as in text book definitions of what a hockey player should be, but for players with the greatest careers and greatest legacies. Therefore the best player is not n…

Top Ten Junior Players Of All Time

Let's take a look at the Top Ten junior players of all time. For the purposes of this list we will at players in the WHL, OHL and QMJHL only.

10. Pat Lafontaine, Verdun, QMJHL Rookie-record 104 goals, 234 points in 1982-83; major junior player of the year.

9. Denis Potvin, Ottawa, OHL 254 games, 95 goals, 234 assists, 329 points. Broke Bobby Orr's junior records.

8. John Tavares, Oshawa, OHL 215 goals, 433 points in 247 games; most goals in OHL history; eligibility rules changed to admit him at 15; 2006 major junior rookie of the year, 2007 major junior player of the year; two world juniors, named 2009 all-star, top forward and MVP.

7. Sidney Crosby, Rimouski, QMJHL 120 goals, 303 points in 121 games; two-time major junior player of the year; silver and gold with Canada at two world juniors.

6. Eric Lindros, Oshawa, OHL 97 goals, 216 points in 95 games; one Memorial Cup victory; three world junior tournaments; major junior player of the year in 1991.

5. Mike Bossy, Laval, Q…

Greatest Hockey Legends: M