October 21, 2022
What If Wayne Gretzky Had No Hart?
Think about that for just a moment.
There was no questioning Wayne Gretzky's dominance, and his decade long league MVP status is exhibit one.
But there were runners-up, and they all deserve some sort of recognition, too. So let's take a look at who was the best player in hockey during each season of the 1980s who was not named Wayne Gretzky.
1980-81 - Mike Liut, 237 votes. Despite setting new NHL record for assists and points in a season, Gretzky barely won this Hart vote with 242 votes. Edmonton struggled despite Gretzky's greatness. Meanwhile in St. Louis goalie Mike Liut was nothing short of spectacular. His peers thought he was the most dominant player that season even, voting him as the Lester Pearson award winner (now known as the Ted Lindsay Award.). Other Finalist: Marcel Dionne (24 votes)
1981-82 - Bryan Trottier, 130 votes. This wasn't even close. How could it be? Gretzky scored 92 goals and 212 points and earned 315 votes. Trottier, the 1979 Hart Trophy winner, had a heck of a season, too, with 50 goals and 129 points. Other Finalist: Mike Bossy (34 votes).
1982-83 - Pete Peeters, 159 votes. Peeters had one of the hottest goaltending performances ever, registering a 40-11-9 record and a 2.36 GAA. But it wasn't close as Gretz, who had 196 points this season, had 266 votes. Other Finalist: Denis Savard (67 votes).
1984-85 - Dale Hawerchuk, 91 votes. Another 200+ point season means another Hart vote that is not even close as Gretzky gets 303 votes. But Hawerchuk fuels the Winnipeg Jets with 53 goals and 130 points, third best in the league behind Gretzky and Jari Kurri. Other Finalist: Pelle Lindberg (56 votes)
1985-86 - Mario Lemieux, 130 votes. With a record setting 163 assists and 215 points they should have just used Gretzky's 281 votes to suggest renaming the trophy after him. But young Mario Lemieux, the man who would one day take the Hart away from Gretzky, has a fantastic season, too. He scores 48 goals, 93 assists and 141 points. Other Finalist: Mark Howe (32 points).
1986-87 - Ray Bourque, 95 votes. No one comes close to Gretz's 255 votes but Boston's standout defenseman Ray Bourque puts up 95 points while playing stellar defense. Other Finalist: Mike Liut (39 votes).
1988-89 - Mario Lemieux, 187 votes. Even though Mario outscored Gretzky 199 points to 168, Hart Trophy votes gave Gretzky the decided edge with 267 votes. It was Gretzky's first year in LA and he helped turned the lowly Kings into playoff threats. Other Finalist: Steve Yzerman (109 votes).